big five · ocean

The five traits, one at a time

The Big Five is the model academic psychology actually uses. Not five types — five dimensions, each a continuous scale you sit somewhere on rather than a box you fall into.

OCEAN is the usual mnemonic: Openness, Conscientiousness, Extraversion, Agreeableness, Neuroticism. The traits were not designed — they fell out of statistical analysis of the words languages use to describe people, which is why they are oddly named and unusually well replicated.

How to read a Big Five result

Three things trip people up. Scores are percentiles against a norm group, so the answer to "is 70 high?" depends entirely on who you were compared against. There is no good or bad end of any scale — every trait has costs at both extremes, which is why the pages below describe high and low side by side rather than treating one as the default. And the middle is where most people are: a score near the 50th percentile is a real result, not an inconclusive one.

One more: traits move. Conscientiousness and agreeableness rise with age for almost everyone, openness declines, and neuroticism is the most responsive of the five to circumstances and to therapy. A result five years old is describing a person who no longer entirely exists.

Big Five vs MBTI

The two models are answering different questions, which is why the comparison usually generates more heat than it should. The MBTI sorts people into sixteen categories; the Big Five places them on five continuous scales. If you score just past a cutoff on the MBTI you change type, and if you score just past the middle on the Big Five you move a percentile point.

That is the substantive difference and it is the reason academic psychology uses the Big Five almost exclusively: continuous measures are more stable on retest, and categories at a cutoff are not. What the MBTI has instead is a vocabulary people find usable, which is not nothing — but it is a different kind of value from predictive validity.

The honest position is that both are self-report instruments measuring preferences, that neither diagnoses anything, and that the Big Five is the one with the research behind it.

The sixteen MBTI types →